Employee Share Schemes

Quick Insights: Overview of ESS Types & Their Suitability

Series 2: Employee Share Scheme Costs, Growth & Taxation

Dive into the details of how to set up Employee Share Schemes effectively, from growth shares and hurdle rates to essential documentation and common pitfalls. 

Wrapping up our series on ‘Costs, Growth & Taxation’ of Employee Share Schemes (ESS), our final Quick Insight focuses on the different types of ESS available and their suitability for UK startups. Choosing the right type of share scheme is pivotal in aligning employee incentives with your company’s growth objectives and can significantly impact both recruitment and retention. So, let’s dive right in!

Types of Employee Share Schemes

  1. Enterprise Management Incentive (EMI):

    • Best for: High-growth potential startups looking to retain key talent.
    • Features: Offers significant tax advantages, both for employers and employees, and flexible terms. It’s specifically designed for small to medium-sized enterprises with assets of £30 million or less.
  2. Save As You Earn (SAYE):

    • Best for: Companies of all sizes that want to offer a risk-free savings route to their employees.
    • Features: Employees save monthly, with the option to buy shares at a discounted price at the end of the saving period. No Income Tax or NICs on the difference between the purchase price and market value.
  3. Share Incentive Plan (SIP):

    • Best for: Companies looking to offer a share ownership stake to all employees on an egalitarian basis.
    • Features: Employees can receive shares as free shares, partnership shares, or matching shares, with favourable tax treatment if held within the plan for a certain period.
  4. Company Share Option Plan (CSOP):

    • Best for: Medium to large companies that want to provide managers and key employees with the option to purchase shares.
    • Features: Offers tax benefits, although not as generous as EMI, and allows more flexibility than EMI in terms of company size and valuation.

Choosing the Right Scheme

Selecting the appropriate ESS depends on several factors:

  • Company Size and Stage: Smaller, high-growth startups might favor EMIs for their tax advantages, while larger corporations might lean towards CSOPs or SIPs.
  • Goals of the Scheme: Whether the aim is broad employee ownership or rewarding a few key individuals can determine which scheme fits best.
  • Tax Considerations: Each scheme has different tax implications for both the company and the participants, which need to be carefully considered.

Final Thoughts

With this overview of various Employee Share Schemes, we wrap up our ‘Costs, Growth & Taxation’ series! We’ve delved into schemes like EMI, SAYE, SIP, and CSOP, each tailored for different stages and sizes of UK startups. Choosing the right ESS is critical for maximizing your team’s potential and aligning employee incentives with your company’s growth targets.

As we conclude this series, get ready for an even deeper dive coming your way. Our upcoming Series 3, titled “Choosing the Right Scheme for You,” launching in June, will explore each type of ESS in detail. We’ll guide you through the decision-making process, ensuring you select the ESS that best fits your startup’s specific needs and goals. Stay tuned!

Considering your employee share scheme options? Let Elliott Gaspar, Standard Ledger’s Founding UK Director, help you untangle the specifics. With expertise in financial strategy and a track record of supporting startups, Elliott can provide you with the insights you need to make informed decisions. Book your free, no-obligation chat today!

We’re for founders

Connect with other founders + learn about equity, valuations, funding and more at our events.

We’re for founders

Connect with other founders + learn about equity, valuations, funding and more at our events.

More articles

In collaboration with Equidam, we dive into essential tips for valuing your startup effectively.
Find out about the essential documentation you'll need to compile for your SEIS/EIS application - from business plans to financial statements & more.
Set a solid foundation for success by following these key steps when preparing to apply to the SEIS or EIS.

We’re here while you build your dream

And for everything in between